Good to Great
In one line
Stop hunting for a dramatic breakthrough; get the right people, face the truth, and keep pushing one clear direction until momentum does the work.
The scene
In 1971, Darwin Smith became chief executive of Kimberly-Clark, a Wisconsin paper company. Within weeks, doctors told him he had nose and throat cancer and about a year to live. The board discussed whether to replace him. He stayed. He flew to Houston for radiation treatment and kept running the company. He lived and worked for another twenty years.
Smith was not a showman. Jim Collins describes him as shy and awkward, dressed in plain clothes, with none of the swagger people expected from a big-company boss. What he did have was a hard look at his own business. He decided that its core product, coated paper, would never be great. So he sold the paper mills that had been the company's heritage. He put the money into consumer products, like tissues and diapers, and took on Scott Paper and Procter & Gamble.
Wall Street analysts downgraded the stock. Smith did not change course. By the time he retired in 1991, Kimberly-Clark had beaten Scott Paper in most of the categories where they competed. Its shares had returned about four times the market's over his two decades.
Collins uses Smith as his main example of a leader who is quiet and stubborn at once.
The big idea
Collins and his research team started with 1,435 companies. They looked for a very specific pattern: fifteen years of ordinary stock returns, then a jump to at least three times the market for the next fifteen. Only eleven passed. They then studied each one next to a similar company that did not make the jump.
The pattern they found was dull on purpose. None of the eleven had a famous, celebrity-style leader or a bold new strategy announced to the press. Ten of the eleven CEOs were insiders. The companies did not lurch from one big program to the next. Collins describes a flywheel: a heavy wheel you push in one direction, turn after turn. No single push looks like much, but the pushes add up. The weaker companies did the opposite. They launched a new program, saw little result, lost patience, and started over. Collins calls that the doom loop.
This works because it matches how results build. Each push adds to the last, and a company that never changes direction keeps every push. A company that keeps restarting throws them all away.
Greatness comes from disciplined people pushing one clear direction for years, not from one big move.
Read it if / Skip it if
- Read it if you lead a team, a business or yourself, and want a plain, evidence-based map of how steady organizations pull away from average ones.
- Skip it if you only need the main ideas. The chapter summaries below cover most of it, though the case studies carry real weight.
How it works
Lead with humility and a spine. Collins calls the best leaders "Level 5": personally modest, professionally fierce. When things went well, they pointed out the window, crediting others and good luck. When things went badly, they looked in the mirror and took the blame. The shift for you: stop asking how to look like a leader and ask what the work needs. Smith never needed credit. He needed Kimberly-Clark to become something different.
Choose people before you choose a plan. Collins says to get the right people on the bus, the wrong people off, and the right people in the right seats, and only then decide where the bus goes. The shift: a clear plan with the wrong team fails, while a good team can change course when the world changes. Before a big project, ask first who will do it, then what to do.
Look at the facts you would rather avoid. Collins tells of his conversation with Admiral James Stockdale, who spent over seven years as a prisoner of war in Vietnam, starting in 1965. Stockdale told Collins the optimists were the ones who died: they kept saying they'd be out by Christmas, then Easter, and eventually their hearts gave out. Collins names this the Stockdale Paradox: keep faith that you will prevail, and also face the worst of your current situation. This also covers failure. Smith treated the weak paper business as information, not an insult, and acted on it. The shift for you: a bad number or a rejection becomes data about what to change.
Find the one thing you can be best at. Collins's "Hedgehog Concept" is three overlapping questions: what you can be best in the world at, what drives your economics, and what you are deeply passionate about. Walgreens, one of his eleven, built its approach around profit per customer visit. Where the circles overlap, you stop trying everything. The shift: you stop saying yes to work that doesn't fit all three.
Where it breaks
The strongest criticism is about method. Phil Rosenzweig's book The Halo Effect argues that Collins picked companies by their results, then studied them for the qualities that explain those results. That can produce neat stories after the fact, because people describe a winning company as disciplined and a losing one as sloppy. Collins also looked at only eleven companies, which is a small group for such confident rules.
Time was unkind. Several of the eleven later faltered badly. Circuit City went bankrupt in 2009, and Fannie Mae was at the centre of the 2008 financial crisis. Collins responded with a later book, How the Mighty Fall, which describes five stages of decline.
The book also leans toward large, established, mostly American companies. A fast-moving startup, a family firm or a creative studio may find "wait and push" less helpful. And luck gets little room in a story that is mostly about discipline.
Do this Monday
Write a "stop doing" list: three things you do each week that don't fit your one best thing, with a name or time next to each. Take ten minutes, on one card, and put it where you plan your week. Done means you can name the first one you will drop by Friday.
The repeatable practice: every Friday, spend two minutes checking whether you really stopped that item. Add one new item only after dropping an old one.
The Wall Note
- Look out the window for credit; look in the mirror for blame.
- Pick people first, plans second.
- Say the hard fact out loud this week.
- Believe you'll win; check the facts anyway.
- Find the one thing you can be best at.
- Keep a stop-doing list.
- Push the same wheel tomorrow.
- Don't restart because it feels slow.
Send this to someone
This is for your friend who starts a new project, plan or side business every few months and drops it just before it would have worked. They keep restarting a wheel that never gets its momentum.
Message: "Read Good to Great's flywheel chapter. Might be why none of our big plans stick — we keep resetting the wheel."
Sources
- Jim Collins's official site, with research summaries and the book's concepts: the author's own description of the study and its ideas.
- Harvard Business Review, "Level 5 Leadership: The Triumph of Humility and Fierce Resolve": Collins's article on the leadership finding, including the Kimberly-Clark story.
- Good to Great on Wikipedia: an independent overview that includes the book's criticism and the later fate of its companies.
Get the full book
To get the full depth of the research and its case studies, pick up Jim Collins's Good to Great (HarperBusiness/HarperCollins) — amazon.com/dp/0066620996, at bookshops, or your local library.
This is an original editorial commentary created for personal inspiration. All ideas, frameworks, proprietary concept names, and registered trademarks belong to their respective authors and publishers — this site is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the author or publisher. No sentences or passages from the original book are reproduced verbatim. This summary is not a substitute for the original work. We strongly encourage you to read the full book.
Rate 1-5 when you like.